What is schema therapy? The 18 early maladaptive schemas, modes and how it works
CareOps editorial team · · 11 min read
Mental wellness information and service guidance published by CareOps.
About the CareOps editorial team
The CareOps editorial team publishes these guides. Sources are linked at the end of each article; examples are illustrative, not customer stories. Product descriptions refer to CareOps Maeumi. Publication and revision dates appear above.
Read our full editorial standards →You thought this time would be different, yet you end up with the same kind of person again. People tell you you're doing well, but the voice saying “not good enough” won't stop. If you understand this in your head and still keep landing in the same place, there may be an old mental template underneath. Schema therapy is a psychotherapy built to work on that template.
At a glance
- Schema therapy is a psychotherapy that helps you recognize and change long-running mental patterns (schemas) that grew out of unmet emotional needs in childhood. Jeffrey Young developed it by extending cognitive behavioral therapy.
- Its core concepts are 18 early maladaptive schemas, need domains, coping styles (surrender, avoidance, overcompensation) and modes. Treatment combines imagery rescripting, chairwork and the therapist's “limited reparenting.”
- It has mainly been studied, with positive results, for personality disorders, especially borderline personality disorder. It is usually a long treatment of a year or more, and because it touches painful memories it is done with a therapist.
What is schema therapy?
In psychology, a schema is a long-standing template for how you see yourself, other people and the world. Templates aren't bad in themselves, and they help us make sense of things quickly. But one formed through painful experiences can keep distorting how you see reality well into adulthood.
Schema therapy is an integrative psychotherapy developed by the American psychologist Jeffrey Young. To address long-standing difficulties that didn't respond well to cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT) alone, it adds ideas from Gestalt therapy and psychoanalysis. The goal is to learn how to meet, in healthy ways, the core emotional needs that went unmet in childhood.
Schemas are thought to form where inborn temperament meets the childhood environment. A meta-analysis of 33 studies (Pilkington and colleagues, 2021) found childhood neglect and abuse were associated with schemas in adulthood. But most of those studies looked at a single point in time, so cause can't be established, and the concept isn't meant to put the blame on a parent.
The 18 early maladaptive schemas
Jeffrey Young organized early maladaptive schemas into 18 types. The sentences on the right are examples written for this post. This table is not a test. Most people relate to a few of them a little, and relating to one doesn't mean something is wrong with you.
| Schema | What it might sound like |
|---|---|
| Abandonment/instability | The people I love will end up leaving me |
| Mistrust/abuse | Sooner or later people will use or hurt me |
| Emotional deprivation | No one truly understands how I feel |
| Defectiveness/shame | If people knew the real me, no one would like me |
| Social isolation/alienation | I don't belong anywhere |
| Dependence/incompetence | I can't do anything on my own |
| Vulnerability to harm or illness | Something terrible could happen at any moment |
| Enmeshment/undeveloped self | Without that person I don't know who I am |
| Failure to achieve | I can't do as well as other people |
| Entitlement/grandiosity | The rules don't really apply to me |
| Insufficient self-control | Holding back is too hard, I'll just do it now |
| Subjugation | Something bad will happen if I say what I want |
| Self-sacrifice | Other people's needs come before mine |
| Approval-seeking | Without recognition I have no worth |
| Negativity/pessimism | It won't work out anyway |
| Emotional inhibition | I must not show my feelings |
| Unrelenting standards | This still isn't good enough |
| Punitiveness | Mistakes deserve to be punished |
The International Society of Schema Therapy groups the 18 into five domains of core childhood needs, such as connection, mutuality and autonomy. How they are grouped varies by study; an analysis of 1,054 people (Bach and colleagues, 2018) found four groupings fit best. In treatment, schema questionnaires and interviews are used together to explore your patterns with a professional.
Three coping styles: surrender, avoidance and overcompensation
Even with the same schema, people cope differently. Taking the defectiveness schema, “I'm not good enough,” as an example, it might look like this.
| Coping style | What it does | Defectiveness example |
|---|---|---|
| Surrender | Accepting the schema as true and going along with it | Staying with someone who treats you badly |
| Avoidance | Steering clear of situations or feelings that trigger it | Not letting anyone get close |
| Overcompensation | Pushing hard in the opposite direction | Trying to look perfect or putting others down |
These styles may once have been survival strategies that protected you as a child. The trouble is that they keep running automatically in adulthood and end up strengthening the schema. If you're worn out from pleasing people, see the good child complex; if you fear being left, see abandonment anxiety; and if the “not enough” voice is loud, see perfectionism.
What are schema modes?
If a schema is an old template, a mode is the state you're in right now when that template gets triggered. Feeling fine, then suddenly hurt like a small child after one comment, or abruptly feeling nothing at all, are examples of switching modes. Young's institute lists ten common modes in four groups.
| Group | Mode | What it looks like |
|---|---|---|
| Child | Vulnerable Child | Feeling lonely, scared and small |
| Child | Angry Child | Rage when needs go unmet |
| Child | Impulsive Child | Acting on whatever you want right now |
| Child | Contented Child | Relaxed, playful and at ease |
| Coping | Compliant Surrenderer | Giving in for fear of conflict |
| Coping | Detached Protector | Shutting off feelings and pulling away |
| Coping | Overcompensator | Coming on stronger or showing off |
| Inner parent | Punitive Parent | A voice that harshly punishes you |
| Inner parent | Demanding Parent | A voice that pushes you to do better |
| Healthy self | Healthy Adult | Caring for the vulnerable self and setting limits |
Put simply, treatment aims to strengthen the Healthy Adult mode: caring for the vulnerable part of you, setting fair limits on anger and impulses, and standing up to the voice that punishes you. If that harsh voice is loud, see self-hatred too.
How does schema therapy work?
You first explore your current difficulties and life story to identify your schemas and coping styles. Then you work on changing them with methods like these.
- Limited reparenting: within the boundaries of the therapy relationship, the therapist partly offers the understanding and care you missed as a child. This is the most distinctive feature of schema therapy.
- Imagery rescripting: after bringing up a painful memory, you rewrite the scene in your imagination so the protection and care you needed happens.
- Chairwork: facing an empty chair, you talk with your inner critical voice or the hurt part of you.
- Cognitive work: weighing the evidence for and against a schema.
- Changing behavior patterns: practicing new behaviors in daily life in place of your usual coping.
It tends to be long. For personality disorders it usually takes a year or more, with individual or group sessions once or twice a week or every other week. In research, the length has ranged from 50 sessions (Bamelis and colleagues, 2014) to twice weekly for three years (Giesen-Bloo and colleagues, 2006).
Does schema therapy work? What research shows
- Borderline personality disorder: in a three-year randomized trial of 88 people (Giesen-Bloo and colleagues, 2006), those in schema therapy were about 2.2 times as likely to recover as those in transference-focused psychotherapy. In a trial at 15 sites in five countries (Arntz and colleagues, 2022), combined individual and group schema therapy had better outcomes and retention than usual treatment.
- Several personality disorders: in a trial of 323 people (Bamelis and colleagues, 2014), 50 sessions of schema therapy led to more recovery at three years and less dropout than usual treatment.
- Overall: a meta-analysis of eight randomized trials with 587 people (Zhang and colleagues, 2023) reported a moderate effect on personality disorder symptoms (g = 0.359).
- Depression: a trial comparing 100 people (Carter and colleagues, 2013) found outcomes similar to CBT. The authors noted the study needs replication.
There are limits too. It has been studied less than CBT, and in the 323-person trial, unlike interview-based ratings, self-report measures showed no difference. A mainly group format did no better than usual treatment in the 2022 trial, so how format affects results still needs study. Evidence for problems beyond personality disorders is thinner.
Hard parts and cautions
Because it works with old wounds, strong emotions can come up during treatment. The length can make it expensive, and because it relies on a close therapeutic relationship, there is a noted risk of becoming emotionally dependent on the therapist. Choose a therapist you trust, keep boundaries clear and speak up right away if symptoms get worse.
What you can do on your own: noticing your patterns
Work that goes into painful memories, such as imagery rescripting, belongs with a therapist. On your own, stick to picking one recent moment in daily life that really shook you and noticing the pattern.
- Briefly write down the moment: what happened and what you felt.
- Find the sentence in your head, such as “Of course I'm going to be left.”
- Name what you did: did you give in (surrender), steer clear (avoidance) or come on stronger (overcompensation)?
- Write one line in your Healthy Adult voice, as you would to a close friend: “That hurt. It doesn't mean you've been abandoned.”
- Choose one small thing to try differently next time, such as saying “Let me think about it” instead of agreeing right away.
When to work with a professional
If the same relationship problems keep repeating, you feel like hurting yourself, or childhood memories are shaking your daily life, talk with a psychiatrist or counseling center. When booking, you can ask whether they have schema therapy training. Diagnosis and medication are decided in clinical care, and psychotherapy can go alongside it. How it compares with other approaches is in types of psychotherapy.
How do you see yourself lately? A self-esteem check
The Rosenberg self-esteem check is not a schema test, but its ten items can help you reflect on how you've been seeing yourself lately. You can take it right away, with no login.
Try a self-assessment without signing inSelf-esteem (RSES)How you value and respect yourself. Answer the app’s questionnaire and see your result right away.Start the check →If you'd like someone to look at your patterns with you
Patterns are hard to see on your own, and even when you notice one it's easy to forget. CareOps Maeumi is an AI counseling app that runs sessions with research-backed approaches. Using methods such as cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT) and acceptance and commitment therapy (ACT), it looks with you at the scenes that keep repeating and the thoughts behind them, helps you choose a small action and remembers past sessions so the next one continues from there. You can also use it alongside clinical care or counseling. Get the app
Frequently asked questions
- What does schema therapy mean?
- It is a psychotherapy that helps you recognize and change long-running mental patterns (schemas) that grew out of unmet emotional needs in childhood. Jeffrey Young developed it by adding ideas from Gestalt therapy and psychoanalysis to CBT.
- How is schema therapy different from CBT?
- While CBT mainly works on current thoughts and behaviors, schema therapy also addresses the older templates and childhood needs beneath them. It uses limited reparenting within the therapy relationship, imagery rescripting and chairwork, and it tends to take longer.
- How can I find out my schemas? Is there a test?
- In treatment, schema questionnaires and interviews are used together with a professional. It's best not to define yourself by a quick online quiz. On your own, writing down your thoughts and actions in moments that shook you can start to reveal repeating patterns.
- How long does schema therapy take?
- It is usually long-term. For personality disorders it typically takes a year or more, with sessions once or twice a week or every other week. In research, the length ranged from 50 sessions to three years. It depends on what you're working on, so you decide with your therapist.
- Who is schema therapy a good fit for?
- It has mainly been studied for personality disorders, especially borderline personality disorder. People whose relationship patterns keep repeating or who haven't improved with other treatments may consider it. Research continues on depression, eating problems and panic, but the evidence is still limited.
Sources
- Schema Therapy Institute (Jeffrey Young), 18 Early Schemas Defined
- Schema Therapy Institute (Jeffrey Young), Schema Mode Listing
- International Society of Schema Therapy, Schema Therapy Central Concepts
- Cleveland Clinic, Schema Therapy
- Bach et al. (2018), A new look at the schema therapy model: organization and role of early maladaptive schemas, Cognitive Behaviour Therapy 47, 328–349
- Pilkington et al. (2021), Adverse childhood experiences and early maladaptive schemas in adulthood: A systematic review and meta-analysis, Clinical Psychology & Psychotherapy 28, 569–584
- Giesen-Bloo et al. (2006), Outpatient psychotherapy for borderline personality disorder: randomized trial of schema-focused therapy vs transference-focused psychotherapy, Archives of General Psychiatry 63, 649–658
- Bamelis et al. (2014), Results of a multicenter randomized controlled trial of the clinical effectiveness of schema therapy for personality disorders, American Journal of Psychiatry 171, 305–322
- Arntz et al. (2022), Effectiveness of Predominantly Group Schema Therapy and Combined Individual and Group Schema Therapy for Borderline Personality Disorder, JAMA Psychiatry 79, 287–299
- Zhang et al. (2023), The efficacy of schema therapy for personality disorders: a systematic review and meta-analysis, Nordic Journal of Psychiatry 77, 641–650
- Carter et al. (2013), Psychotherapy for depression: a randomized clinical trial comparing schema therapy and cognitive behavior therapy, Journal of Affective Disorders 151, 500–505
- Masley et al. (2012), A systematic review of the evidence base for Schema Therapy, Cognitive Behaviour Therapy 41, 185–202
This guide shares mental wellness information. If you are in immediate danger, contact emergency services where you are. Support and contact information.